How many things in the photo below do you think are new pieces vs. reclaimed pieces? I love how put together and rich this looks while still looking lived-in. There's a certain nobility that comes from furniture and decor that aren't right out of the box. A reclaimed piece that speaks to you is, in my opinion, a good way to avoid the "McMansion" look.
Unless of course you're into that kind of thing...
image via apartment 412